Experiments in Aesthetics and Politics

The Poetic Mundane in Hale County This Morning, This Evening

Published on: December 19, 2022
By: Charlotte Gavin

On Friday, October 28th at the Armory Center for the Arts in Pasadena, Shana L. Redmond presented a talk, “‘Agencies of Menace’ – The State, the Car, and the Music in Between” that included fragments of her monograph in progress, Dark Prelude: Black Life before Mourning. As a scholar of race and popular music in America, Redmond’s work is generally concerned with the political dimensions of music and its relation to social movements. With this new project, her focus is to illuminate Black living and the presence of music in the moments before tragedy. She is guided by “the mundane and pressing need to know those moments before and elsewhere.” Redmond’s method is to write about real events and real people (e.g., Sandra Bland and Assata Shakur), but construct educated guesses of the specific songs or artists they were listening to and how they must’ve felt in the instance before facing violence and/or death. Redmond’s research pulls data from music charts, autobiographies, Black representation in films, car stereo systems and police dash cam footage to imagine the scene before drive-by shootings, carjackings or any other form of brutality that Black individuals are disproportionately subjected to. The project is an effort towards interrogating the role of the state, social justice organizations, and scholars in advancing constructions of Blackness that exist exclusively on a death spectrum. Redmond works in alliance with the writer Hanif Abdurraqib, whose book Little Devil in America was quoted in Redmond’s lecture: “If only all movies about Black people struggling against the machinery of this country were instead movies about Black people living.” The image of Black suffering prevails in American culture, and although Redmond is challenging this through her compositions of the “moments before,” there is still an inevitable doom as to what happens next that surrounds the subjects she is writing on.

Hale County This Morning, This Evening—a documentary film shot, directed, and edited by RaMell Ross—aligns exquisitely with Abdurraqib’s statement, and takes Redmond’s intentions a step further into a visual story of Blackness and challenges how Black folks have come to be seen. Ross showcases the “epic-banal,” a term he applies to his practice of ​​crafting enchanting landscapes of ordinary moments that string together into an ethereal backdrop. In its essence, the film is a 76-minute montage, made over the course of a few years, of interior spaces, exterior spaces, families, and multiple generations of the Black community living in Hale County, Alabama. Black safe spacecars, churches, porches, living rooms—and the ambient sounds of living fill the canvas. Its artistic considerations, astonishing visual and sonic compositions, and the blending of the surreal, the real, and the impressionistic evokes expansive visions of daily existence. Shots of the rural land, the sun rising, an eclipse, stars in the sky, and clouds formations interlace with ordinary activities such as playing basketball, watching television, frying food, getting haircuts and riding bikes. The film evolved out of the time Ross spent in Hale County teaching basketball and photography and lovingly observing the lives within the community. The main subjects are two young men, Quincy and Daniel, and the surrounding people in their lives; Mary (Daniel’s mother), Boosie (Quincy’s significant other), and Kyrie (Quincy and Boosie’s toddler son). Quincy and Daniel are often on screen sharing with Ross the intimate details of their ambitions, fears, and dreams: Daniel is on a journey playing college basketball with the aspiration of becoming a pro player, and Quincy is supporting and building a family. 

Boosie and Daniel with newborn
Basketball practice

There are several distinct moments in the film where the presence of music is revealed, explicitly reflecting Redmond’s emphasis on the musical details of Black life and safe spaces. At the sixteen-minute mark, two young girls are at an outdoor gathering showing Ross and the camera a “toy”an energizer battery with an attached wire and miniature lightbulb. As they show off their thrill from the science of electricity, “Love and Happiness” by Al Green is playing from speakers in the background. 

The girls with their battery toy 

Another scene shot from a distance focuses on three teenage girls, appearing as silhouettes, standing under a terrace in the nighttime as a thunderstorm emerges. They are singing (beautifully) Etta James’ “I’d Rather Go Blind” in unison: “Something told me it was over/When I saw you and her talkin’.” Unsure of the lyrics at one point (”talkin or “walkin”) they break off and the moment ends. These scenes are the real life visions of the moments Redmond is seeking to construct through educated guesses. 

In addition to music’s omnipresence, the film depicts how music is a tool for navigating pain. During an intimate scene in a church space, we watch a female pastor lead a service via song. Everyone in the room is either dancing, wailing, or singing and no attention is made towards the camera in the room. At one point, there’s a low-angle shot of Daniel, who’s looking at the ground, swaying and crying. Moments of joy, boredom, or pain are depicted in fragments, often without context, but nevertheless reveal life’s spectrum of emotions and how they come and go and come back and go away again. The camera does not linger on any given emotion or experience for too long. As soon as there’s an air of sadness or grief, there quickly comes delight and joy shortly thereafter. Viewers are left with their instinctual response to each passing moment. The lack of information and the whiplash energy of time paradoxically allows the viewer to see the subjects more clearly. 

In conversation with the Hammer Museum, Ross discusses the inspiration he gets from the lack of banality in the media’s depiction of what it is to be Black: “most Black folks that watch the film appreciate that the film shows the way in which they look at their children or the way in which we look at our children. As opposed to a lot of white audiences are like “oh look at the intimacy” or “look at the access, I haven’t seen these moments before.” Black viewers know and have lived the moments depicted in Hale County, This Morning, This Evening, but have rarely seen them in traditional film. It’s difficult to sell the banal, but Ross’ vision and attention to detail renders it in compelling ways without exploiting the moment itself. Ross consistently emphasizes youth throughout the film by evoking an experience through the perspective of children. During a conversation between Mary and Daniel, the camera’s focus is on Mary’s younger daughter, Shodedra. Mary is braiding Shodedra’s hair while complaining to Daniel about wanting alone time. Shodedra turns to Ross, looks into the camera, and smiles faintly as a single tear rolls down her cheek. We as viewers don’t know why the tear is there, but it’s acknowledged and experienced in a context where she is otherwise ignored. 

A similar but longer moment is oriented towards Kyrie, Quincy, and Boosie’s son. The camera is at eye level as he paces back and forth, entertaining himself in the family room. The TV is on in the background, there’s conversation coming from another room, and we see the lower half of an adult, presumably Quincy, sitting on the couch. Eventually, Kyrie runs up to Ross and performatively pants into the camera.

Kyrie’s moment

The scene then cuts to Kyrie and Quincy cuddling and roughhousing on the couch next to Boosie, who is now pregnant with twins. 

The film’s most tragic facet is reflected with emotional nuance. Viewers are brought into the delivery room when Boosie’s in labor with the twins, and Ross fixates on the exhaustion and excitement of childbirth. The camera fixates on Quincy as he nods off in the fluorescent room dressed in medical garb, then cuts to Boosie’s face and close-ups of the cesarean birth as the twins’ are delivered: Karmyn and Korbyn. The next scene is an extended shot of the two newborns, side by side, safe and cozy in their respective car seats, conjuring a yearning to be as protected and loved as a newborn baby. As the shot lingers and the adoration grows, the camera cuts to a butterfly hovering over grass, and a title card reading “Korbyn was buried in the early afternoon. . . Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.” Viewers experience the emotional intensity of having just watched Korbyn and Karmyn sleeping peacefully together to the immediate pain felt for Quincy and Boosie. Ross briefly shows moments of grief with a distant shot of the funeral service and a quick scene of Boosie in their living room, frozen still with her head tucked in her arms. As time passes, the mourning transforms into positive memorialization. Ross is in the backseat of the car as Boosie and Quincy order food at a Wendy’s drive-thru. Boosie is laughing at her phone background, a photo of Korbyn crying that she “can’t stop looking at.” “He was a mama’s boy,” she says. 

Ross is committed to an exhibition of care that is sought by Redmond as well, portraying his subjects’ experiences beautifully and empathetically. The bond and trust between Ross and the subjects gives a natural depth to the simplest occurrences, and the mundane carries the film’s expansiveness. Ross’s role as a witness, especially around a grieving family, is profoundly respectful and places him as a proxy for viewers. His position as a peer enables the viewer to feel the care towards the community that permeates throughout the film, and offers a rare, poetic and intimate method into documentary filmmaking. Ross executes what Redmond wants to see more of in entertainment, scholarship, and social justice movements, but does so in an almost indirect way. Redmond believes that both the media and social organizations tell us nothing about how Black people live, and while her work is a blunt attempt to put pressure on the kinds of questions we ask about violence, the role of the state, and Black representation, Ross’ film takes on a more subtle approach to opposing the powers that be. Redmond’s Dark Prelude: Black Life before Mourning focuses on Black living in an effort to implicate the State, social justice organizations, and scholars for their roles in advancing representations of Blackness that exist on a death spectrum. In doing this, she imagines the joyful moments before inevitable tragedy. For Ross, there’s no explicit commentary on racism, racial violence or state violence in the film, aside from a brief moment where Daniel gets pulled over. The tension in the scene puts the viewer in a position to expect violence that never delivers, making them contemplate their association with Blackness as tethered to an expectation of death. Ross is merely depicting life as it is for the Black community living in Hale County, Alabama, and in doing so he protests against the stereotypes and the expectations of Black representation.

Works Cited

The Hammer Museum, Post-screening Q&A: “Hale County This Morning, This Evening.”

Hale County This Morning, This Evening, Directed by RaMell Ross, Louverture Films, 2018.


...Show All Tags
... And Couting 2018 Guangzhou Triennial 2020 abolition activism advertising aesthetics Aesthetics & Politics Aesthetics and politics affect Afro-Futurism afropessimism agonism ai AI art Aidrley Queiros Aimee Bahng algorithmic bias alt-right alum alumni American history American Mythologies anarcha-feminism Anarchafeminism Anarchism andrea fontenot Andy Warhol animal studies anime Anthropocene anti-abortion anti-blackness Antiaesthetics aporetic argentina aria dean Armor art Art Critic Art History Art prompt artificial intelligence Asia asian american art Asian Art Asian Futurity assembly associations aural auto-fiction automation Beijing Being Human beluga Biswas Mellamphy Black lives matter black out black studies black study Blm blockchain Blondie body Boots Riley borderlands Branco Sai Preto Fica Brasil bratich Bridget Crone Bring springer CalArts California Institute of the Arts calvin l. warren calvin warren Capital capital is dead capitalism carceral tech carceral technologies carceral technology care Carlos Villa cars CBGB CCM Censorship Charity Chiara Bottici china Chinese Art chinese philosophy Christian Dior Christopher Kulendran Thomas chronology cinema citizneship class Claude Monet collective Colombia Coloniality comics Community computer science Contemporary Art Contemporary Chinese Art content moderation control coronavirus Cosmetics covid Covid-19 creaturely criminal justice Crisis Criticism Critique crypto Cuba Cuba Revolution Cuban Art culture curation Dance Daniela Lieja Quintanar data data collection data sourcing Debbie Harry decoloniality Dennis Cooper desire Deway-Hagbord Diaspora dictee digital digital art digital culture Digital Media digital tools diversity Documentation Donna Haraway Doris Salcedo DOXA drag Drag King drag name drifting drones ecological ecology Ed Fornieles Édouard Glissant Eminem emory Empathy exhibition experimental experimental film experimentalpublication exploitation extinction facial hair Fascism fash-wave fashion feminism fiction film flicker fluxus foreign labor foucault franco barchiesi Frank O'Hara FREEPLAY Futura 2000 gabriel rockhill gas Gean Moreno gender geography Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari Gloria Anzaldua Grebowicz Halston Hannah Arendt Hauntology Havana Hermeneutics hip hop hipsters Hiroshi Fujiwara historicism HIV/AIDS horror human Human rights hypebeasts hyper-masculinity identity im here to learn so :)))))) image theory impressionism individuation industrial revolution industrialization infrapolitics Infrastructure Instagram Installation Intelligence Gathering Intelligence Led Policing Intergalactix internet internet of things INTERPRETATION intersectionality intimacy Invisible Hand irony j kameron carter Jaar jack bratich Jack Burnham Jazz Jean-François Lyotard Jemima Wyman Jennifer Ponce de Leon John-Michael Rivera Judith Butler Julian Stallabrass Kara Keeling Karina Alma kathy acker Kettling Khademi kinging koreanamericanliterature Kubra Khademi LA LA RIver lapd LARPing larval warfare Larvas Warfare LATERAL Latin America Latin-America Latino American Latinx Studies Latipa Laurie Anderson Les Immatériaux exhibition libidinal Line Dance linette park Lisa Nakamura Los Angeles Los Angeles Contemporary Exhibitions loss Louis Vuitton Luciana Parisi Mahakali Manuel Shartzberg Marc Jacobs Marianne Hirsh marketing Marvel marxism masculinity matias viegener Maurice Merleau-Ponty mckenzie wark Medea media theory Mellamphy memory metaphysics METHOD metic Mètis MGMT Misael Oquendo montage mourning Mudd Club museum Music Nan Z. Da Nandita Biswas Mellamphy Necro-Politics Necropolitics net art NFT nicholas mirzeoff Nike niunamenos noc non-fungible tokens nonhuman nylan October ontological terror ontology packers paint tube painting panopticism Parametricism Patrik Schumacher Paul Preciado Performance persuasion Peru Pettman phantasmagoria photography pleasure plurality Poetics poetry poiesis police police state police training politics pop music popular culture Pose post-human post-millennial Postmemory Predictive Policing PrEP prison abolition psychology punk QUANTITATIVE quarantine queer queer calculus queer media Queer Theory ra judy Race race and racialization Rachel Garfield Racial Empathy rationality READING Real Abstraction reality reductionism resistance Revolution rhizome Rihanna Robot Skin Ronak Kapadia Rosalind Krauss RuPaul Ryan Murphy Sarah T. Roberts sci-fi Science Fiction screenshot Sculpture sentient flesh SHAKESPEARE ShanaL Redmond skin Skoghall Konsthall smart cities smart city sneakers social media Socialism sociology Soft Science Fiction Software exhibition solitude sonic sonic voice sound space spatial justice spectacle and counter spectacle Speculative Fiction speed Spin Sri Lankan civil war Stephen Sprouse Stop LAPD Spying Coalition structural film structuralism STRUCTURE student repression subcultures suggestion superheroes Surveillance Susan Buck-Morss Swarm Intelligence syllabus systems analysis systems art Systems Esthetics T5311 Taylor Swift techno-orientalism temporality Teresa Margolles terror TEXT The Aesthetics of Net Art the archive The Body the disappointment the imaginal The Modular Body The Postmodern Condition the refrain the sky opened up with answers the tiller girls The Zapatistas Theorist in Residence theory theresahakkyungcha Thierry de Duve Thor thought experiments TikTok time Tomás Esson trans fem aesthetics trans literature Transindividual transindividuality trauma Undocumented UNDOCUMENTS Urban Space Victoria Ivanova Video Art video essay vignette virality Virtual Reality visibility visual activism visual categories visual culture Visual Studies Visuality voice VR wafaa bilal war on terror War on Youth whale WHAP Womanhood Yiyun Li Zac's Haunted House Zach Blas

Other posts by this author