Experiments in Aesthetics and Politics

Metis and Lain

Published on: October 30, 2019
By: Elizabeth Jaffari

On October 18th, 2019, Nandita Biswas Mellamphy, an Associate Professor at Western University, delivered a public lecture at the West Hollywood Public Library as part of the WHAP! Series hosted by the MA in Aesthetics & Politics Program at the California Institute of the Arts. The public Lecture is entitled, “Larval Warfare and Predatory Politics.” This essay considers how the 1998 anime Serial Experiments Lain explores themes from her work.

Information in this time of extraordinary technological development is a precious commodity. The entity that has information has the power to control, distribute, and edit the information they are in possession of. It is a game of deception and nonlinear modes of travel through the digital landscape to trap information and use it to your advantage. This game of information trapping and the blurring of physical/digital reality, also known as “metic warfare” by Nandita Biswas Mellamphy, is how warfare is fought and won in this age of constant technological development. “Metic warfare” is the reality that science-fiction and cyberpunk stories once described come to real life, where deception and chaos are tactics through the use of technical objects to trick and trap information and create weapons to destroy the boundaries of the human, digital and nature.

“Metic warfare,” as explained by Mellamphy, is a way of life that emerges from the passage of information from one digital matrix to another by way of métissage. Métissage is a French word meaning a mix or cross-pollination. For Mellamphy, “metic warfare” is enacted by information that mixes or cross-pollinates between multiple digital matrices, such as government security information databases to social media databases. Métissage, in the case of Mellamphy, is essential for understanding her use of “metic warfare.” Instead of simply mixing information, Mellamphy suggests that information relaying is best understood as a deceptive and strategic process.

Another piece to the puzzle of metic warfare is Mellamphy’s essay “Ghost in the Shell-Game: On the Metic Mode of Existence, Inception and Innocence,” in which she refers to Mamoru Oshii’s film Inosensu (also known as Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence for English audiences). She argues that technical objects, namely digital matrices, act as mediators between human and nature as well as a world of “inner memory and subjectivity” (3). In their roles as mediators, the existence of digital matrices have an asymmetric power over humans and nature. Thus, Mellamphy defines the existence of technical objects as Metic. She derives the term Metic from the Greek Titaness Metis, who is a symbol of cunning wisdom and a destroyer of natural order. Mellamphy has elaborated on Metis elsewhere, namely in her essay “(w)omen out/of Time: Metis, Medea, Mahakali,” in which she describes Metis as “fluid, mobile, ever-masked, and polymorphous; metis can bind elements but also can escape a bond by transforming itself” (15). She leads her to use the term “Metis” in conjunction with the idea of “Metic warfare” as a “mode of cunning intelligence that belongs not to war or the city but to technics, namely the machinations of hunting and trapping (not symmetrical and agonistic but asymmetrical and deceptive)” (“Ghost in the Shell-Game” 10).

How is this all relevant to how we imagine the internet? In the film, Inosensu, gynoids (doll-like sex robots) serve as metic agents that hunt and trap thier owners to achieve their goal. Mellamphy uses them as a way to describe asymmetric enemies that have cunning intelligence. The gynoids know, with the help of a hacker, act like ghosts, former humans whose consciousness have been uploaded into a machine or shell. The gynoids are polymorphus in their reproducibility. Their cunning intelligence comes from their awakening from the help of a malfunction into their programing that helps them hunt, trick and trap those who feel own them, the humans. They target their owners through deception and ultimately eliminate their owners.thus, like the titan Metis represents, the gynoids use their cunning intelligence to disrupt the natural order of human and machine and engage in “metic warfare.”

Though I agree with Mellaphy in her use of the gynoids to depict Metic warfare, further examples of techno/human relations and metic warfare are common themes across many other cyber-punk and Japanese science fiction anime and manga. Here, I would like to explore one: the character Lain from the anime series Serial Experiments Lain, who embodies a polymorphous identity whose actions follow principles of metic warfare that are rooted clearly in terror: the terror she causes her users both in and out of the digital matrix called “The Wired.”

In Japan, between July 1998 to September 1998, the 13-episode anime Serial Experiments Lain aired alongside mech sci-fi animes, such as the Gundam franchise and Neon Genesis Evangelion. What Serial Experiments Lain added was an avant-garde mystery that delved into the human psyche, such as our growing dependence on the internet. Its approach was fresh given that the World Wide Web was publicly released in 1991 and AOL’s instant messaging had launched in 1997. Though there were early precursors, with the internet being conceived in the 1960’s and the concept of a “digital matrix” described for decades in the books of Do Androids dream of Electric Sheep by Philip K, Dick (1968), Neuromancer by William Gibson (1984), and even the original manga for Ghost in the Shell (1989). Serial Experiments Lain offered a reaction to and exploration of the new reality of the internet that had been newly released and used among adolescence more frequently. It was written as a cautionary tale of dependence on technology, emphasizing how its adoption can become almost religious and habitual. Moreover, the series also predicted new types of warfare under the direction of polymorphous servers and algorithmic deities that interact in and out of physical/digital reality, like Lain herself.

Within the first episode, a form of “metic warfare”already  begins with Lain, a school girl who is seemingly aloof to technology and “The Wired,” after she receives a series of messages.  The messages come from her classmate Chisa, who commited suicide the day before. They inform Lain that Chisa is not really dead, but rather, that she has only given up her corporeal reality to join “The Wired.” The reason she gives?: “God is here.” (Ep. 1 “Weird,” 13:48). The scene further elaborates what Mellamphy is arguing about technical objects. The computer and the “The Wired” serve as technical objects as they mediate between human, digital, and the natural world. This mediation is fluid and omniscient, enabling Chisa to transcend death by becoming digital, which allows her to appear once more in Lain and other students’ physical realities. This instigates Lain to dive deep into “The Wired” only to find out that there are multiple Lains there. Each employs their own means of controlling, trapping, and deceiving users of “The Wired,”  manipulating their realities both in and out of the digital landscape. As the episodes progress, so do the mythical and deity qualities of Lain and her all-knowing power.

The metic Lain’s further embodies larval terror as she surveils and blackmails her classmates. Paranoia and disillusionment enters each user as Lain undertakes her campaign of fear. Her actions follow what Mellamphy describes as larval terror, creating “an affective state in which we may sense some – we may feel it viscerally – that we can’t identify, quantify or qualify”(“Larval Terror” 3). For example, Lain’s alter identity confronts a disillusioned gunman with the words “No matter where you go, everyone’s connected” as he enters a nightclub (Episode 2 “Girls”). The ambiguous statement that “everyone’s connected” serves as a psychological threat to the gunman, so contaminating his mind that he flips his gun and fires it on himself. “Everyone” is an asymmetric terror that Lain uses to trick and manipulate the users of her system; This terror is an asymmetric one because it is a faceless, immeasurable terror that is unpredictable as to when and where it can strike its target, which in many cases the target of this faceless terror may not know it is being targeted. The inability to differentiate between friend and enemy results in a paranoia so severe that the man attempts to sever his ties with both worlds. This is how Lain wins this metic game, by tricking and trapping the man for his data, winning his consciousness to grow her own knowledge and power.

She, Lain, is designed to destroy the barrier between the world of the “Wired” and the human world. She mobilizes “metic” and “larval warfare” through asymmetric terror as an all-knowing and polymorphous being that infiltrates daily human life. The digital is everywhere and even passive interaction with digital matrices, such as social media platforms and google searches, unknowing users fall prey to predatory algorithms that track and capture their data. In an extreme example, drone warfare uses “metic warfare” to trick and trap their next target by capturing their information. All the while their targets are unaware that they have been targeted and soon will be eliminated. It is a removed and disillusioned way of fighting that evokes paranoia and insecurity to both the prey and predator; It is deceptive and chaotic on both ends of the battle field. The “Wired” or the internet are technical objects in the daily life of contemporary human society. If the existence of technical objects is metic and technical objects are mediators between the human and nature then existence itself is deception and chaos.

Works Cited

Mellamphy, Nandita B.“Ghost in the Shell-Game: On the Metic Mode of Existence, Inception and Innocence” Funambulist Paper. No.46. pp 3, 10. 

Mellamphy, Nandita B. “Larval Terror and the Digital Darkside.” E-International Relations, 14 Nov. 2015. pp 3

Mellamphy, Nandita B. “( ᵂ )omen out/of Time: Metis, Medea, Mahakali.” 2016. pp 15

Nakamura, Ryutaro, and Yoshitoshi Abe, director and producer. Serial Experiments Lain. TV Tokyo, 1998.

...Show All Tags
... And Couting 2018 Guangzhou Triennial 2020 abolition activism advertising aesthetics Aesthetics & Politics Aesthetics and politics affect Afro-Futurism afropessimism agonism ai AI art Aidrley Queiros Aimee Bahng algorithmic bias alt-right alum alumni American history American Mythologies anarcha-feminism Anarchafeminism Anarchism andrea fontenot Andy Warhol animal studies anime Anthropocene anti-abortion anti-blackness Antiaesthetics aporetic argentina aria dean Armor art Art Critic Art History Art prompt artificial intelligence Asia asian american art Asian Art Asian Futurity assembly associations aural auto-fiction automation Beijing Being Human beluga Biswas Mellamphy Black lives matter black out black studies black study Blm blockchain Blondie body Boots Riley borderlands Branco Sai Preto Fica Brasil bratich Bridget Crone Bring springer CalArts California Institute of the Arts calvin l. warren calvin warren Capital capital is dead capitalism carceral tech carceral technologies carceral technology care Carlos Villa cars CBGB CCM Censorship Charity Chiara Bottici china Chinese Art chinese philosophy Christian Dior Christopher Kulendran Thomas chronology cinema citizneship class Claude Monet collective Colombia Coloniality comics Community computer science Contemporary Art Contemporary Chinese Art content moderation control coronavirus Cosmetics covid Covid-19 creaturely criminal justice Crisis Criticism Critique crypto Cuba Cuba Revolution Cuban Art culture curation Dance Daniela Lieja Quintanar data data collection data sourcing Debbie Harry decoloniality Dennis Cooper desire Deway-Hagbord Diaspora dictee digital digital art digital culture Digital Media digital tools diversity Documentation Donna Haraway Doris Salcedo DOXA drag Drag King drag name drifting drones ecological ecology Ed Fornieles Édouard Glissant Eminem emory Empathy exhibition experimental experimental film experimentalpublication exploitation extinction facial hair Fascism fash-wave fashion feminism fiction film flicker fluxus foreign labor foucault franco barchiesi Frank O'Hara FREEPLAY Futura 2000 gabriel rockhill gas Gean Moreno gender geography Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari Gloria Anzaldua Grebowicz Halston Hannah Arendt Hauntology Havana Hermeneutics hip hop hipsters Hiroshi Fujiwara historicism HIV/AIDS horror human Human rights hypebeasts hyper-masculinity identity im here to learn so :)))))) image theory impressionism individuation industrial revolution industrialization infrapolitics Infrastructure Instagram Installation Intelligence Gathering Intelligence Led Policing Intergalactix internet internet of things INTERPRETATION intersectionality intimacy Invisible Hand irony j kameron carter Jaar jack bratich Jack Burnham Jazz Jean-François Lyotard Jemima Wyman Jennifer Ponce de Leon John-Michael Rivera Judith Butler Julian Stallabrass Kara Keeling Karina Alma kathy acker Kettling Khademi kinging koreanamericanliterature Kubra Khademi LA LA RIver lapd LARPing larval warfare Larvas Warfare LATERAL Latin America Latin-America Latino American Latinx Studies Latipa Laurie Anderson Les Immatériaux exhibition libidinal Line Dance linette park Lisa Nakamura Los Angeles Los Angeles Contemporary Exhibitions loss Louis Vuitton Luciana Parisi Mahakali Manuel Shartzberg Marc Jacobs Marianne Hirsh marketing Marvel marxism masculinity matias viegener Maurice Merleau-Ponty mckenzie wark Medea media theory Mellamphy memory metaphysics METHOD metic Mètis MGMT Misael Oquendo montage mourning Mudd Club museum Music Nan Z. Da Nandita Biswas Mellamphy Necro-Politics Necropolitics net art NFT nicholas mirzeoff Nike niunamenos noc non-fungible tokens nonhuman nylan October ontological terror ontology packers paint tube painting panopticism Parametricism Patrik Schumacher Paul Preciado Performance persuasion Peru Pettman phantasmagoria photography pleasure plurality Poetics poetry poiesis police police state police training politics pop music popular culture Pose post-human post-millennial Postmemory Predictive Policing PrEP prison abolition psychology punk QUANTITATIVE quarantine queer queer calculus queer media Queer Theory ra judy Race race and racialization Rachel Garfield Racial Empathy rationality READING Real Abstraction reality reductionism resistance Revolution rhizome Rihanna Robot Skin Ronak Kapadia Rosalind Krauss RuPaul Ryan Murphy Sarah T. Roberts sci-fi Science Fiction screenshot Sculpture sentient flesh SHAKESPEARE ShanaL Redmond skin Skoghall Konsthall smart cities smart city sneakers social media Socialism sociology Soft Science Fiction Software exhibition solitude sonic sonic voice sound space spatial justice spectacle and counter spectacle Speculative Fiction speed Spin Sri Lankan civil war Stephen Sprouse Stop LAPD Spying Coalition structural film structuralism STRUCTURE student repression subcultures suggestion superheroes Surveillance Susan Buck-Morss Swarm Intelligence syllabus systems analysis systems art Systems Esthetics T5311 Taylor Swift techno-orientalism temporality Teresa Margolles terror TEXT The Aesthetics of Net Art the archive The Body the disappointment the imaginal The Modular Body The Postmodern Condition the refrain the sky opened up with answers the tiller girls The Zapatistas Theorist in Residence theory theresahakkyungcha Thierry de Duve Thor thought experiments TikTok time Tomás Esson trans fem aesthetics trans literature Transindividual transindividuality trauma Undocumented UNDOCUMENTS Urban Space Victoria Ivanova Video Art video essay vignette virality Virtual Reality visibility visual activism visual categories visual culture Visual Studies Visuality voice VR wafaa bilal war on terror War on Youth whale WHAP Womanhood Yiyun Li Zac's Haunted House Zach Blas

Other posts by this author