Experiments in Aesthetics and Politics

Errant Feminisms: Kara Keeling’s Reading of Two Pop Songs

Published on: October 20, 2018
By: Claudia Griggedo

by Claudia Grigg Edo

On October 26th 2018, Kara Keeling, Associate Professor of Cinema and Media Studies at the University of Chicago will deliver a closed seminar and a public lecture at the West Hollywood Public Library as part of the WHAP series, curated by Sara Mameni on behalf of the Aesthetics & Politics department at California Institute of the Arts. The public lecture, entitled, ‘“I Feel Love”: Race, Gender, Technē, and the (Im)Proper Sonic Habitus,’ will begin at 7:30pm. This post anticipates that talk, responding to ‘ELECTRIC FEEL,’ an essay Keeling published in Cultural Studies journal in 2013.

The essay looks at the possible political effects of a pop song. Specifically: ‘the logics it makes available to a feminism that thinks with its ears.’ This is an obtuse and intimidating proposition to someone like me, who feels like their feminism comes from reading life and books; who panics when asked what music they want to listen to on a date in case the song is received as information; and who empathised with Herr Settembrini in The Magic Mountain when he said that music is politically suspect (because it doesn’t teach new content, it only inflames old content). The logocentrism of Settembrini’s pronouncement has been clear to me for a long time, but it hasn’t changed the way I operate. I listen to music to heighten – or flit between – known moods, or to incite nostalgia. I read books and have conversations in order to change. I am (obviously!) ashamed of this hierarchy I maintain, and received Keeling’s essay as a welcome challenge.

What are these ‘logics’ that pop music can offer feminism? Keeling offers a rewording and elaboration of her aim a few pages later. She states that pop songs ‘offer insightful support for relating concepts to the rapidly changing present circumstances that feminisms might actively participate in shaping.’ This idea of ‘concept production’ is repeated as an aim throughout the essay, but – crucially –the pop songs are not producing concepts alone. They ‘offer support’ to experimental listeners and makers who can put certain pressures on the pop song – recontextualising (‘remixing’) it to animate new meanings and connections.

Keeling calls this experimental recontextualizing ‘errantry’. The word is borrowed from a Martinican philosopher and poet, appropriately named Édouard Glissant. Glissant describes errantry as a mode of relational ontology – whereby one seeks to become many, but without reducing others to a unity:

…one who is errant (which is no longer traveller, discoverer or conqueror) strives to know the totality of the world yet already know he will never accomplish this – and know that is precisely where the threatened beauty of the world resides.

The mode that Glissant conveys is also a mood: an optimistic openness, tempered by an understanding of the dangers and inevitable failure of a will to unity (of the traveller, discoverer or conqueror). It reminds me of Donna Haraway’s ‘irony,’ as expressed in ‘A Cyborg Manifesto’. A playful slippage that understands you cannot merely efface old categories (since to do so would be to efface the history behind them, and the way it has materially accumulated to create specific experiences). But that you can heighten them, put pressure on them, détourné them, draw attention to their made-ness – and thus to the possibility of something else existing in their place: ‘I would rather be a cyborg than a goddess.’

For Keeling this errantry is present in music. She, like Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari, finds a defining tension in music between the ‘refrain’ (defined loosely as inherited formal constraints: ‘where music gets bogged down in existing formations’) and the transformational possibilities of sound. It is the latter – which cannot exist without the former – which prompt or induce the mode or mood of errantry. The ‘transformational multiplicities’ of sound (‘when it takes musical forms’) trigger an affective and intellectual playfulness, that encourage us as listeners to make more of the refrain: to decontextualize it and test it against new contexts. It seems that Keeling thinks that feminism in particular can learn from this specific form of errantry.

Keeling is, crucially, not talking about learning from the underlying message or political unconscious of a song – rather about tensions into which it can be brought; tensions which might bring productive connections to light. This is most clear when she discusses ‘Electric Feel’ by MGMT, an indie synth pop track I danced to when I was 15, and which – I’ve gotta say – produced no errant sense of possible meanings in me.

I said ooh girl
Shock me like an electric eel
Baby girl
Turn me on with your electric feel

For Keeling however, the song invokes ‘electricity’ as a ‘dynamic, self-generating capacity carried in bodies and in nature’ – a force rather than a substance, which does not distinguish human bodies from their surroundings. The ‘voltage running through her skin’ can be transferred: ‘[p]ut your circuits in the sea’. Rather than be disturbed by the lyrics’ fetishization of the ‘exotic girl’ in the ‘exotic woods’ (described respectively as ‘the amazon’ and ‘the eastern shore’), Keeling feels that they prompt a message about ‘unequal global distribution of access to reliable sources of energy’ and thus ‘a pressing need to invent sustainable connections and the sources of energy necessary for their maintenance.’

I understand that Keeling is describing a collaborative mode between music and listener. But her analysis of ‘Electric Feel’ seems, to me, a bit like reading these first two lines of an untitled Frank O’Hara poem –

Light clarity avocado salad in the morning
after all the terrible things I do how amazing it is…

– and surmising that it is about the complex and exploitative production chain that goes into making a white male New Yorker associate avocados with ‘light clarity’ and unexpected ease. Of course it allows us to find those chains, to make new connections – but the entitled insouciance of O’Hara’s poem and Electric Feel’s lyrics are part of the respective works’ effects and affects. Surely they can’t just be pasted over.

Keeling’s analysis is closer to my own affective experience when she turns to Eminem’s 2010 song featuring Rihanna, ‘Love the Way You Lie.’ Quoting Hardt and Negri’s lamentation of contemporary thought’s ‘failure to interrogate and develop’ love, she investigates the kind of love presented in the pop song, before moving onto what it isn’t but could be. The context and subtext of the song, which glorifies a turbulent (read: violent) relationship, is of course Rihanna’s assault by her then-partner Chris Brown the year before it was released. Keeling notes how the song feeds off that high-profile abuse, allowing it to contribute murkily to the intense (and intensely profitable) affect.

Keeling describes two deployments of love in reference to the song. The first, ‘static love,’ is generative (as love always is for Keeling) but the generative impulse is short-circuited – it is fed back into an immobile or destructive pattern. This is what Keeling finds depicted in Eminem and Rihanna’s collaboration. The female voice sung by Rihanna insists she enjoys the pain inflicted on her, but – as Keeling states – this reads as a way to ‘assert a limited agency in a desperate situation and to rationalize surviving the relationship.’ Thus, her claim of finding pleasure in pain stands in for consent ‘in a situation in which the very possibility of ‘consent’ is foreclosed by the terms that sustain’ it, i.e. violence.

Keeling is extremely insightful about the creative processes behind the ways that a victim of domestic violence reinscribes their affective investment in the relationship, as though they had a real choice. She sees these creative processes as reminders of the possibility of a less destructive affective investment: ‘revolutionary love.’ This, defined against ‘static love,’ would respond to violence, not by entrenching the current state of affairs, but by seeking to renegotiate the relationship between ‘selves and others,’ and seeking ‘relation and correspondence with/in difference.’ This is a kind of love propelled by errantry, that allows new contexts to build new connections and imperatives.

Keeling uses the difference between ‘static’ and ‘revolutionary’ love to explicate and propose some errant moves within feminism. She draws fruitful connections between political issues that garner unconditional support from feminist groups – such as anti-domestic violence campaigns – and affectively related issues like prison abolition, which also confront ‘the sticky entanglements involving living beings whose historical relationships to each other have been structured in advance by a quotidian violence over extended periods of time.’ This gives us a sense of the kinds of movements, transductions, expansions that she is invested in. Errantry can borrow from pre-existing feminist refrains to create new logics that expand the context of engagement; that expand what is considered relevant to feminism.

I completely agree with the need for these playful and productive errant slippages. She argues convincingly for extending logics from contexts in which they are familiar and well worn, to those from which they are still foreign. But I am still unsure as to the role of ‘Electric Feel’ and ‘Love the Way You Lie’ in these movements. Of course Keeling is in no small part arguing for our creative participation as listeners – our errant relationship to the music, and our transformation of its refrains. However, it still seems to me important to start with the reigning affect of the songs as they stand – before moving to how we must expand from them.

‘I Love the Way You Lie’ isn’t a song about Rihanna’s short-circuiting love. It’s a song about the extremely profitable intensity that relies on that short-circuit. The character voiced by Eminem is automatically more compelling in his assumption of agency – he could fuck everything up (i.e. keep abusing her) and by doing so hurt himself.

It’s so insane ‘cause when it’s going good, it’s going great
I’m Superman, with the wind at his back, she’s Lois Lane
But when it’s bad, it’s awful
I feel so ashamed, I snapped, who’s that dude
I don’t even know his name, I laid hands on her
I’ll never stoop so low again,
I guess I don’t know my own strength…

The destructive ‘flaw’ in Eminem’s character, communicated in his standard machinegun delivery, interrupts and structures Rihanna’s static position. He could lose everything. She already has, and so occupies a far less dramatic position. To be an errant listener of the song, you have to start by imagining that her choice (about how to love and be loved) could be generative (could change things), not only his.

‘Electric Feel’ does equalize human and non-human substance as all similarly seeking vitality, and can thus be considered errant for its decentring of human energy and experience. However, I would argue, this equalizing is a mood that gains its thrill from being a temporary trip. It derives its ultra-sellable intensity from the (white, Wesleyan-educated) male singer’s erotic submissiveness to his affective surroundings prompted by psychedelia and by the hot touch of an attractive (non-Western?) woman. Rather than encouraging or manifesting errantry, I would argue that ‘Electric Feel’ stages a false errantry – the sensuous intermingling it evokes is only exciting because it is far from what we deem the speaker’s usual position to be. He is submitting (to someone/something less powerful than him) for a while, but this doesn’t change anything long term. Like so many pop songs, I receive it as a testament to the temporary (to the traveller, discoverer or conqueror).

I love Keeling’s deployment of ‘errantry,’ just as I loved Haraway’s ‘irony’. To take known knowns and place them in contexts where they are still unfamiliar strikes me as deeply political. To spend time in a non-logocentric space, allow our imaginations to be moved by the ways in which older forms are animated by sound in music – this is sometimes inevitable but can also become a conscious practice, and is one I would like to expand my experience of. In this post, however, it has felt important to analyse the specific starting points for errantry before we jump off them. To understand the ways in which our steps are guided by the affect they deliver. I see ‘Electric Feel’ and ‘Love the Way You Lie’ as points of resistance rather than facilitators of errantry. We may seek to reinscribe, to transform, to get somewhere else. But I think those efforts should be labelled as such; because errantry is fleeting, hard to feel/do and harder to hold in common.

Claudia Grigg Edo is a graduate student in the Aesthetics & Politics program at CalArts


...Show All Tags
... And Couting 2018 Guangzhou Triennial 2020 abolition activism advertising aesthetics Aesthetics & Politics Aesthetics and politics affect Afro-Futurism afropessimism agonism ai AI art Aidrley Queiros Aimee Bahng algorithmic bias alt-right alum alumni American history American Mythologies anarcha-feminism Anarchafeminism Anarchism andrea fontenot Andy Warhol animal studies anime Anthropocene anti-abortion anti-blackness Antiaesthetics aporetic argentina aria dean Armor art Art Critic Art History Art prompt artificial intelligence Asia asian american art Asian Art Asian Futurity assembly associations aural auto-fiction automation Beijing Being Human beluga Biswas Mellamphy Black lives matter black out black studies black study Blm blockchain Blondie body Boots Riley borderlands Branco Sai Preto Fica Brasil bratich Bridget Crone Bring springer CalArts California Institute of the Arts calvin l. warren calvin warren Capital capital is dead capitalism carceral tech carceral technologies carceral technology care Carlos Villa cars CBGB CCM Censorship Charity Chiara Bottici china Chinese Art chinese philosophy Christian Dior Christopher Kulendran Thomas chronology cinema citizneship class Claude Monet collective Colombia Coloniality comics Community computer science Contemporary Art Contemporary Chinese Art content moderation control coronavirus Cosmetics covid Covid-19 creaturely criminal justice Crisis Criticism Critique crypto Cuba Cuba Revolution Cuban Art culture curation Dance Daniela Lieja Quintanar data data collection data sourcing Debbie Harry decoloniality Dennis Cooper desire Deway-Hagbord Diaspora dictee digital digital art digital culture Digital Media digital tools diversity Documentation Donna Haraway Doris Salcedo DOXA drag Drag King drag name drifting drones ecological ecology Ed Fornieles Édouard Glissant Eminem emory Empathy exhibition experimental experimental film experimentalpublication exploitation extinction facial hair Fascism fash-wave fashion feminism fiction film flicker fluxus foreign labor foucault franco barchiesi Frank O'Hara FREEPLAY Futura 2000 gabriel rockhill gas Gean Moreno gender geography Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari Gloria Anzaldua Grebowicz Halston Hannah Arendt Hauntology Havana Hermeneutics hip hop hipsters Hiroshi Fujiwara historicism HIV/AIDS horror human Human rights hypebeasts hyper-masculinity identity im here to learn so :)))))) image theory impressionism individuation industrial revolution industrialization infrapolitics Infrastructure Instagram Installation Intelligence Gathering Intelligence Led Policing Intergalactix internet internet of things INTERPRETATION intersectionality intimacy Invisible Hand irony j kameron carter Jaar jack bratich Jack Burnham Jazz Jean-François Lyotard Jemima Wyman Jennifer Ponce de Leon John-Michael Rivera Judith Butler Julian Stallabrass Kara Keeling Karina Alma kathy acker Kettling Khademi kinging koreanamericanliterature Kubra Khademi LA LA RIver lapd LARPing larval warfare Larvas Warfare LATERAL Latin America Latin-America Latino American Latinx Studies Latipa Laurie Anderson Les Immatériaux exhibition libidinal Line Dance linette park Lisa Nakamura Los Angeles Los Angeles Contemporary Exhibitions loss Louis Vuitton Luciana Parisi Mahakali Manuel Shartzberg Marc Jacobs Marianne Hirsh marketing Marvel marxism masculinity matias viegener Maurice Merleau-Ponty mckenzie wark Medea media theory Mellamphy memory metaphysics METHOD metic Mètis MGMT Misael Oquendo montage mourning Mudd Club museum Music Nan Z. Da Nandita Biswas Mellamphy Necro-Politics Necropolitics net art NFT nicholas mirzeoff Nike niunamenos noc non-fungible tokens nonhuman nylan October ontological terror ontology packers paint tube painting panopticism Parametricism Patrik Schumacher Paul Preciado Performance persuasion Peru Pettman phantasmagoria photography pleasure plurality Poetics poetry poiesis police police state police training politics pop music popular culture Pose post-human post-millennial Postmemory Predictive Policing PrEP prison abolition psychology punk QUANTITATIVE quarantine queer queer calculus queer media Queer Theory ra judy Race race and racialization Rachel Garfield Racial Empathy rationality READING Real Abstraction reality reductionism resistance Revolution rhizome Rihanna Robot Skin Ronak Kapadia Rosalind Krauss RuPaul Ryan Murphy Sarah T. Roberts sci-fi Science Fiction screenshot Sculpture sentient flesh SHAKESPEARE ShanaL Redmond skin Skoghall Konsthall smart cities smart city sneakers social media Socialism sociology Soft Science Fiction Software exhibition solitude sonic sonic voice sound space spatial justice spectacle and counter spectacle Speculative Fiction speed Spin Sri Lankan civil war Stephen Sprouse Stop LAPD Spying Coalition structural film structuralism STRUCTURE student repression subcultures suggestion superheroes Surveillance Susan Buck-Morss Swarm Intelligence syllabus systems analysis systems art Systems Esthetics T5311 Taylor Swift techno-orientalism temporality Teresa Margolles terror TEXT The Aesthetics of Net Art the archive The Body the disappointment the imaginal The Modular Body The Postmodern Condition the refrain the sky opened up with answers the tiller girls The Zapatistas Theorist in Residence theory theresahakkyungcha Thierry de Duve Thor thought experiments TikTok time Tomás Esson trans fem aesthetics trans literature Transindividual transindividuality trauma Undocumented UNDOCUMENTS Urban Space Victoria Ivanova Video Art video essay vignette virality Virtual Reality visibility visual activism visual categories visual culture Visual Studies Visuality voice VR wafaa bilal war on terror War on Youth whale WHAP Womanhood Yiyun Li Zac's Haunted House Zach Blas

Other posts by this author