OPEN ASSEMBLY

Experiments in Aesthetics and Politics

Beyond the Flicker

Published on: December 12, 2018
By: Lucia Salas
T,O,U,C,H,I,N,G (Paul Sharits, 1968)

Dr. Bridget Crone was a visiting faculty at the Aesthetics and Politics program at CalArts during the fall of 2017.  She is a curator and a writer working at the intersection of political philosophy, media theory, contemporary performance, and moving image practices. Her work explores questions of livenes and the image. As visiting faculty of our school, she was invited to open that academic year’s WHAP series. Her talk on October 6 was titled “Flicker Time: Liquid bodies and cosmic states”.

This talk seems to be expanding some of the work she did for her essay “Flicker-time and fabulation: from flickering images to crazy wipes.” Moreover, this essay and part of her talk concentrate on the film The Flicker by Tony Conrad. In her essay, she explains:

“This essay explores the flicker or flicker-image as a flash of light that has the potential to disrupt the mechanics of vision. The most elemental of images, the flicker is at the very basis of both vision and mechanical image production; it is the flash of light that makes an image possible, and it is the continuous flickering of light across the eye (or lens) that connects visual perception with time perception through the operation of critical flicker frequency: the speed at which the brain joins those flashes of light together and thus perceives the movement of time.”

In the talk, she expands her argument beyond the mechanics of vision in order to consider the political implications of the flicker effect in The Flicker and other materials from films, but also literature. She argues that this elemental image, the flicker, is able to disrupt those mechanics as well as the perception of time as linear. By doing this, she works through the flicker as a way of experiential time travel. 

Tony Conrad’s The Flicker (1966) is a pioneer of a particular type of structural film, flicker films, as characterized by P. Adams Sitney in his book Visionary Film The American Avant-Garde (1943-1978). What they share is the flicker effect, a stroboscopic effect dedicated to the eye. In her text, Crone explains that this effect involves is a specific frequency of flickering at work, the critical flicker frequency. To put it simply, there is a spectrum of durations and intervals that create the flicker effect. If the duration augments and the frequency drops, this effect will not create the usual shock to the eye that the flicker film intends, it will be more a quick alternation than a flicker. All the same, there are no specific rules to flicker films – the flicker deals with the mechanics behind affecting the eye. Films like The Flicker intend to create a strong, slightly dangerous effect. The first shot of The Flicker is a Warning and disclaimer regarding the people that might have an epileptic response to what they are about to see. The flicker effect presents itself here as something slightly dangerous that is also an experience. The message of this plaque seems to be that only a real sensory experience can create such effects. 

The experiences of flicker films differ substantially. In his Arnulf Rainer (1960), Peter Kubelka takes this to the field of image and sound, going a little further into disrupting continuity. Later examples incorporate color and referential images, such as Paul Sharits’ T,O,U,C,H,I,N,G (1968).  Through the years, there have been even digital explorations of the flicker effect, but the material characteristics of digital work are completely different.  The basis of the flicker film is to use alternations that create a discontinuity through moving image, which is perceived as continuous. Crone argues that Conrad’s flicker film allows us to have a sort of immersive experience that would allow us to think and even inhabit the spaces between the images. The intensity of the sensory experience helps the spectator to lose itself between the images.

Standar Gauge (Morgan Fisher, 1984)

But, is there a space between the images? In analog cinema there is a small space between the images. The images that we perceive as continuous when we go to see a film print (an experience that is less common in everyday life, but still very common at CalArts) are in fact discontinuous. What we are seeing are still images projected at a standard speed of 24 frames per second. But as seen above in this still from Morgan Fisher’s Standard Gauge (1984), depicting a small piece of nitrate film, there is a small gap between these images that is necessary for the physical illusion of continuity. That space, as the discontinuity itself, is not perceivable. Indeed, what Conrad, Sharits, and many others are doing is re-claiming the discontinuity of the time-based experience of cinema, against the illusion of continuity. Thus, adding to Crone’s argument of time-related consciousness-raising through discontinuity. Between each still of white that creates the luminous parts of the flicker film, there is a small space. The flicker itself, if it lasts more than a frame, is perceived as a small continuity that is in fact discontinuous.

After drawing the aesthetic implications of the flicker effect, Crone discusses the political implications of this disruptive experience of time and light: The Flicker proposes a new way of seeing and being in the world, thinking outside the norm by abolishing the continuity and transparency that usually comes with narrative cinema. It does this by providing a more embodied experience of watching, both mental and physical (and in this, she summons Deleuze’s famous expressions in his cinema books: give me a body/give me a brain). The flicker film as such creates the experience of inhabiting a different time (thus, time travel), and at the same time, produces a hyper-consciousness of time (both what and how time is). This different experience of time, disruptive and non-linear, she calls “flicker time.” The value that this work holds, for Crone, is how the disruptive embodied experience expands our awareness It is a transformative living experience. Moreover, this experience creates a space of non-productivity, as the person concentrates in the alternations of black and white to the point of extreme immersion.

Reason Over Passion (Joyce Weiland, 1969)

The beginning of Joyce Wieland’s Reason Over Passion (1969) can be thought of as a flicker film. It alternates between images of Canada (including the Canadian flag) and black. The sensation it creates is not only of discontinuity but also of a technical difficulty. The spectator cannot ignore that this film is not magically appearing in a screen, but that it is actually being projected. That is contrary to the usual effect of the “open window to the world” created by continuity and transparency in narrative cinema. The flicker becomes slower and less frequent, and as we see more shots of the Canadian flag, the images keep fading to black, as if it was always trying to start over (turning on, losing strength and disappearing back to zero). Once the images of the landscape acquire continuity, words will appear on top of them. First in French (La Raison Avant la Passion) and then in English (Reason Over Passion), the two official languajes of Canada.  Suddenly, the letters that form the words start to change places, creating new combinations that mostly make no sense as words.The flicker will occur between the words, and the original combination will start to lose meaning and feeling to the point that it is no longer possible to know if it was the reason over the passion or the passion over the reason. By doing this, the film not only creates a confusing experience to the eye, that is always trying to make sense out of the words in the screen, but it also creates the idea of a confusion of the mind, between reason and passion.

Reason Over Passion (Joyce Weiland, 1969)

Like the films Crone mentions, Reason Over Passion is an experiment on drawing attention to the discrepancies between movement and time. Crone brings up that Deleuze, in his cinema books, argues that experimental cinema acts upon or works through the split between the body and the mind. The idea of the “experimental” is not only bound to experimentation but also to experience. The experience of the making but also the experience of watching. All experimental films concentrate primordially on the bodily experience that the spectators have in relation to the work. Crone concentrates in the potential affects that can come from this apparatus, which relates to the body-mind split and the way it can be rejoined. But a question arises from this: while the spectator is having the embodied experience, who is producing it? Whose labor is making this possible for the others?

Picture and Sound Rushes (Morgan Fisher, 1973)

Morgan Fisher is a filmmaker whose work circles around the film apparatus and the way cinema works in different levels, from the mechanics of vision to the politics of viewing. He is also strangely connected to Crone’s talk in a more direct way, as he edited one of the other films she analyzed in her talk, the cult horror film Messiah of Evil.  In his film Picture and Sound Rushes (1973), he describes a film as something in which “there are two basic components, picture and sound. Each of this components can be present or absent,” which relates directly to Tony Conrad’s work, in which there is a sense of the white parts being the presence of the image and the black parts being the absence of it – as white implies the presence of light and black, its absence. Fisher, as Conrad, is looking at film in its most elemental materials. Both their works are dedicated to understanding what is that combination of image and sound and how is it that they work.

Standar Gauge (Morgan Fisher, 1984)

In Standard Gauge, Fisher starts by explaining the technological development of the camera and the projector, from Edison’s individual machine, the kinetoscope (in which one person could look at moving images through a peephole), to the collective experience of the Lumière brothers, who had a machine that could both capture image and project onto a surface for people to see. The film shows selections of 35mm films that can be seen complete, perforations included. They are treated as fragments of celluloid and nitrate instead of being projected at their regular speed. They are viewed as in an operations table. He talks about the 35mm format and the way it is the standard format everywhere, and the culture around this standard – even the fragility of some of the materials of which the standard gauge was made, like the highly flammable nitrate film. He does not create a perceptual effect of discontinuity like Conrad and his flicker, but still he addresses directly the work behind the illusion of continuity that is necessary for a film to exist as such. Both go against that illusion of continuity: one through the senses, and one through a combination of this and an analysis of the differential labors and techniques necessary to make a film, from the crew to the “china girls,” those images of Caucasian women surrounded by colors and tone schemes that are used to calibrate color and luminosity while processing a film. The standard skin tone, the one the density of the material is prepared to react better to, is white.

Projection Instructions (Morgan Fisher, 1976)

A few weeks ago, there was a projection of some of Fisher’s work downtown at REDCAT as part of his exhibition titled, of course, Passing Time. Included in the program was his film Projection Instructions (1976). Luckily for me, the projectionist was a friend of mine, so I heard about some of what she had to do for the screening/performance. As its name suggests, Projection Instructions includes a series of instructions for the projectionist, which are written in white words in a black background. Similar to Conrad’s film, it starts with a notice. This time, not for the spectator but for the projectionist. The disruption of the experience of the spectator here is complete, as they are not the focus, the projectionist is. It forcibly transforms the film theater laborer into a performer, who has to perform some sort of cinematic score made out of actions from their daily work, such as “Throw out of focus” or “Turn off the lamp.”

Half of a decentering of the spectator and the filmmaker from the cinema experience seems to be taking place. The focus shifts to the projectionist, and so does the importance of the actions. The theater worker becomes a performer. This denaturalizes the experience that usually takes place inside the theater, makes visible a labor that is usually invisible. At the same time, the projectionist has little chance to refuse the orders that come from the film. Projectionists are one of the people that make the experience of watching this film possible while being the only ones that can have a fully embodied experience of it. For accomplishing this performance, my friend, who knew the film, had to practice two or three times before the public screening.

I think the work of Morgan Fisher among others helps to answer some of the questions Crone poses in her essays and public talk, as well as it creates new ones. This question regards continuity and disruption in the cinematographic experience, both towards the mechanics of vision and the politics of this mechanics. At the same time, they create a space for experiencing time and denaturalize this experience. By way of a conclusion, itself perhaps flickering: someone once said about Fisher’s Phi Phenomenon, which shows a shot of a clock without the second hand, that while watching it, he realized that a big part of what we pay for watching is not more than minutes passing.


...Show All Tags
... And Couting 2018 Guangzhou Triennial 2020 abolition activism advertising aesthetics Aesthetics & Politics Aesthetics and politics affect Afro-Futurism afropessimism agonism ai AI art Aidrley Queiros Aimee Bahng algorithmic bias alt-right alum alumni American history American Mythologies anarcha-feminism Anarchafeminism Anarchism andrea fontenot Andy Warhol animal studies anime Anthropocene anti-abortion anti-blackness Antiaesthetics aporetic argentina aria dean Armor art Art Critic Art History Art prompt artificial intelligence Asia asian american art Asian Art Asian Futurity assembly associations aural auto-fiction automation Beijing Being Human beluga Biswas Mellamphy Black lives matter black out black studies black study Blm blockchain Blondie body Boots Riley borderlands Branco Sai Preto Fica Brasil bratich Bridget Crone Bring springer CalArts California Institute of the Arts calvin l. warren calvin warren Capital capital is dead capitalism carceral tech carceral technologies carceral technology care Carlos Villa cars CBGB CCM Censorship Charity Chiara Bottici china Chinese Art chinese philosophy Christian Dior Christopher Kulendran Thomas chronology cinema citizneship class Claude Monet collective Colombia Coloniality comics Community computer science Contemporary Art Contemporary Chinese Art content moderation control coronavirus Cosmetics covid Covid-19 creaturely criminal justice Crisis Criticism Critique crypto Cuba Cuba Revolution Cuban Art culture curation Dance Daniela Lieja Quintanar data data collection data sourcing Debbie Harry decoloniality Dennis Cooper desire Deway-Hagbord Diaspora dictee digital digital art digital culture Digital Media digital tools diversity Documentation Donna Haraway Doris Salcedo DOXA drag Drag King drag name drifting drones ecological ecology Ed Fornieles Édouard Glissant Eminem emory Empathy exhibition experimental experimental film experimentalpublication exploitation extinction facial hair Fascism fash-wave fashion feminism fiction film flicker fluxus foreign labor foucault franco barchiesi Frank O'Hara FREEPLAY Futura 2000 gabriel rockhill gas Gean Moreno gender geography Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari Gloria Anzaldua Grebowicz Halston Hannah Arendt Hauntology Havana Hermeneutics hip hop hipsters Hiroshi Fujiwara historicism HIV/AIDS horror human Human rights hypebeasts hyper-masculinity identity im here to learn so :)))))) image theory impressionism individuation industrial revolution industrialization infrapolitics Infrastructure Instagram Installation Intelligence Gathering Intelligence Led Policing Intergalactix internet internet of things INTERPRETATION intersectionality intimacy Invisible Hand irony j kameron carter Jaar jack bratich Jack Burnham Jazz Jean-François Lyotard Jemima Wyman Jennifer Ponce de Leon John-Michael Rivera Judith Butler Julian Stallabrass Kara Keeling Karina Alma kathy acker Kettling Khademi kinging koreanamericanliterature Kubra Khademi LA LA RIver lapd LARPing larval warfare Larvas Warfare LATERAL Latin America Latin-America Latino American Latinx Studies Latipa Laurie Anderson Les Immatériaux exhibition libidinal Line Dance linette park Lisa Nakamura Los Angeles Los Angeles Contemporary Exhibitions loss Louis Vuitton Luciana Parisi Mahakali Manuel Shartzberg Marc Jacobs Marianne Hirsh marketing Marvel marxism masculinity matias viegener Maurice Merleau-Ponty mckenzie wark Medea media theory Mellamphy memory metaphysics METHOD metic Mètis MGMT Misael Oquendo montage mourning Mudd Club museum Music Nan Z. Da Nandita Biswas Mellamphy Necro-Politics Necropolitics net art NFT nicholas mirzeoff Nike niunamenos noc non-fungible tokens nonhuman nylan October ontological terror ontology packers paint tube painting panopticism Parametricism Patrik Schumacher Paul Preciado Performance persuasion Peru Pettman phantasmagoria photography pleasure plurality Poetics poetry poiesis police police state police training politics pop music popular culture Pose post-human post-millennial Postmemory Predictive Policing PrEP prison abolition psychology punk QUANTITATIVE quarantine queer queer calculus queer media Queer Theory ra judy Race race and racialization Rachel Garfield Racial Empathy rationality READING Real Abstraction reality reductionism resistance Revolution rhizome Rihanna Robot Skin Ronak Kapadia Rosalind Krauss RuPaul Ryan Murphy Sarah T. Roberts sci-fi Science Fiction screenshot Sculpture sentient flesh SHAKESPEARE ShanaL Redmond skin Skoghall Konsthall smart cities smart city sneakers social media Socialism sociology Soft Science Fiction Software exhibition solitude sonic sonic voice sound space spatial justice spectacle and counter spectacle Speculative Fiction speed Spin Sri Lankan civil war Stephen Sprouse Stop LAPD Spying Coalition structural film structuralism STRUCTURE student repression subcultures suggestion superheroes Surveillance Susan Buck-Morss Swarm Intelligence syllabus systems analysis systems art Systems Esthetics T5311 Taylor Swift techno-orientalism temporality Teresa Margolles terror TEXT The Aesthetics of Net Art the archive The Body the disappointment the imaginal The Modular Body The Postmodern Condition the refrain the sky opened up with answers the tiller girls The Zapatistas Theorist in Residence theory theresahakkyungcha Thierry de Duve Thor thought experiments TikTok time Tomás Esson trans fem aesthetics trans literature Transindividual transindividuality trauma Undocumented UNDOCUMENTS Urban Space Victoria Ivanova Video Art video essay vignette virality Virtual Reality visibility visual activism visual categories visual culture Visual Studies Visuality voice VR wafaa bilal war on terror War on Youth whale WHAP Womanhood Yiyun Li Zac's Haunted House Zach Blas

Other posts by this author